Recruitment: Generating Maximum Reach – are you getting in front of Passive candidates?

In the first of a series of articles, Adam Keable from Colt Mackenzie McNair offers advice on recruiting staff for your golf club:

After speaking with employers following an advertised led recruitment campaign, they are often very surprised at how little reach their job advertisement received. 

It is so often the case that many employers are overoptimistic about the number of qualified applicants they will receive when advertising a job. From an internal viewpoint they feel that the role they’re looking to fill is an attractive position, and should receive a strong response from good candidates. However more often than not a large percentage of suitable candidates fail to read or are even aware of the opportunity. This is why it is crucial that you understand the candidate market and how they can be split into two key categories: Active or Passive. 

An Active candidate is someone actively looking for new employment and is scanning job boards daily, posting their CV online and is highly motivated to seek new employment.

The Active candidate market is typically comprised of:

  • Candidates in jeopardy of losing their jobs.
  • Candidates that have already lost their jobs.
  • Candidates that are underperforming in their current positions and are upset because they were passed up for a promotion or didn’t receive a pay increase.
  • Candidates with personality or other conflict issues with their peers and/or supervisors.
  • And a small percentage of candidates that are performing and have other reasons to change companies, such as no growth potential, relocation, etc.
  • As only 5 – 20% of the candidate market are ‘actively seeking’ opportunities, 80% of candidates are focused on their current position. These passive candidates are not observing at job boards or trade magazines, which are traditionally used to advertise roles. 

It is not to say that there are no quality candidates in the active market, but it is vital that you identify their motivations for a move as they are not always positive. 

A Passive candidate is someone not actively looking for a new job and is focused on their current role. Generally these candidates are too busy being successful and making an impact in their role. Job boards and advertisements will not reach them and even if they do, it is usually too late. The challenge with passive candidates is that they are harder to identify, locate and qualify.

As passive candidates are in almost all cases considered more desirable than active candidates, it is essential recruitment process focuses on both active and passive candidates. 

So before you rush into advertising a role, ensure that the process you have selected focuses on both the active and passive candidate markets. If you can, form a hybrid methodology that focuses on providing you with the maximum reach so that candidates in both markets are aware of the opportunity. 

Also as we live in a world of technology, ensure that your chosen trade magazine, job board or recruiter can provide you with search analytics, detailing the reach. They should be able to provide this in both number of candidates reached and also quality of candidates reached.

Lastly if budgetary reasons or seniority of the role means that you can only use traditional advertised methods, ensure that you chose the right networks to advertise in. It is always worth a discussion with an Executive Search Firm as they may have networks that you will not have access to.

Colt Mackenzie McNair (CMM) offer trusted recruitment solutions to the golf club industry. CMM provide consultancy advice and recruitment solutions for a wide range of clubs across the UK.

By GCMA

More from Your Community

Close

Allister Frost


A former Microsoft Digital Strategy leader who now inspires audiences to discover the life-enhancing benefits of having a Future Ready Mindset. As a tech pioneer, Allister gained unique insights into how to transform uncertainty into opportunity, and now loves giving others the positive mindset and simple habits needed to:

  • Stay resilient in the face of uncertainty and change
  • Spot quick win opportunities for improvement
  • And *create* a brilliant future!

 

With AI and robots coming for our jobs (hint from Allister: they won’t, if we know how…), many people are anxious about the future. But Allister asserts that we’ve nothing to fear when we leverage our human superpowers and ingenuity to thrive alongside emerging technologies. That’s why having a Future Ready Mindset is now a must-have skill to remain competitive and relevant to the people we serve, our golf club members and the local community. And the best bit: everyone can do it!

This will close in 0 seconds

John Steele


John Steele is a former professional athlete, sports coach, Olympic Leader and is the Executive Director of Sport at Loughborough University. He has been Chief Executive across a range of sectors. Drawing on leadership experience of nine different Olympic and Paralympic Games (including the amazing events at the Rio Games), John reflects on the lessons from this unique period in British sport and relays his fascinating views on creating high performing teams.

Indeed, inspired from PyeongChang 2018 Olympic Winter Games, by the most successful performance ever for Team GB, he has a whole host of new business and leadership insights into how this was brilliant performance was achieved and how it can translate back into your organisation.

John moved into the corporate world, before he enjoyed an outstanding career as a professional rugby player achieving international honours. After his playing career, he turned his hand to coaching and achieved the highest accolade for a British club coach by winning the European Cup with Northampton Saints. He then became Executive Director on the Saints Board during a period of unprecedented growth, and served on the England Rugby Board during the successful world cup campaign of 2003. It was no surprise that John’s talents were called upon to drive through a change and modernisation programme as CEO of the Rugby Football Union – a challenge that became controversial and ended in his departure from the post after only a year, but with his dignity and professional pride intact.

Headhunted by UK Sport, John took up post as CEO the day before London won the 2012 Olympic bid – and this promising start was sustained as he embarked on developing the UK’s high performance sport system, which he led for a six-year period of unprecedented success through the Beijing and London Olympic and Paralympic Games.

Post-London 2012, with the Olympic legacy in place and an obligation to continue inspiring a generation, John took up his post as Group Chief Executive of the Youth Sport Trust. He has also succeeded Steve Cram as Chairman of the English Institute of Sport, an organisation described as ‘the team behind the team’, which delivers a range of performance impacting solutions to over 40 Olympic and Paralympic sports and some non-Olympic sports.

This will close in 0 seconds

Dr Jo Salter MBE


Dr Jo Salter MBE is famed for becoming the first female fast jet pilot, having flown the Panavia Tornado ground attack aircraft during her services in the Royal Air Force. Joining the RAF aged 18, Jo has since taken Air Cadets into the skies as part of Air Experience Flights, become the Director of Global Transformative Leadership for PWC, and most recently become a Global Advisory of GenAI for PwC.

Jo has piloted flights in the Air Cadets Air Experience Flights and inspired countless budding armed service members to pioneer a male-dominated sector, having been the leader of an all-male squadron. Since leaving the military behind, Jo has established a strong business career working in roles such as Head of Technical Services for NetConnect, European Operations Manager for Automated Power Exchange and Managing Director of Saltin Ltd.

Having developed first-class expertise in leadership, analytical thinking and performing under pressure, Jo is now a highly sought-after public speaker to share stories from her time in the skies.

Jo is a passionate Trustee of The Royal Air Force Club and an Ambassador of the Global Angels charity, an organisation that gives communities around the world access to clean water, education, healthcare and encourages female and youth empowerment. Jo has also authored two books, titled Energy: 52 Ways to Fire Up Your Life and Become an Energy Angel and Energize: Spring Clean Your Mind and Body to Get Your Bounce Back Today and Every Day.

In recognition of her achievements throughout her career, Jo has also been named as one of the 50 Most Inspiring Women in the World by Harpers & Queen. She is now working as the Director of Global Transformation Leadership at PWC, after working in other roles such as Director of Risk Technology Strategy, Director Chief of Staff to Head of Technology & Investments and the Director of People & Organisations.

In 2022, Jo was invited personally by Tom Cruise to attend the premiere of Top Gun: Maverick. Most recently, Jo received an honorary doctorate of Arts from Bournemouth University.

This will close in 0 seconds

Colin MacLachlan


Colin Maclachlan, star of Channel Four's captivating reality TV drama SAS: Who Dares Wins and Channel 5’s ‘Secrets of the SAS’, is an operator with over 25 years of security and risk related experience who is a popular and frequent fixture on the speaking circuit.

Colin Maclachlan, celebrated for his roles on Channel Four's SAS: Who Dares Wins and Channel 5’s Secrets of the SAS, brings over three decades of expertise in security and risk management. Colin's military career began in 1989, and after serving nine years with the Royal Scots, he joined the elite 22 SAS at just 23. His time in the SAS saw him participating in numerous high-stakes operations, including the notable rescue of hostages from the West Side Boys in Sierra Leone—a mission so perilous it was dubbed Operation Certain Death.

Colin was also pivotal during the longest hostage siege on UK soil, when a hijacked Afghan plane landed in London in 2000. The standoff lasted four days with Colin as the first sniper on the scene.

After leaving the SAS, Colin exchanged insights with international forces such as Delta Force and Seal Team 6 and provided security consultancy to the Saudi Royal Family and various celebrities. His academic pursuits led him to earn a First Class MA (Hons.) in History from Edinburgh University and an M.Litt in Terrorism from St. Andrews University.

Today, Colin extends his expertise through television, books, radio, and video games. He supports numerous charities and has founded Who Dares Cares, which assists veterans and those experiencing stress. As a speaker, Colin excels in discussing Resilience, Teamwork and Leadership.

This will close in 0 seconds